Saturday, August 30, 2008

Is John McCain Mentally Fit To Be President?

The Huffington Post, 8-30-08

In a breathtakingly puzzling move, John McCain on Friday showed terrible judgment by selecting first term Alaska Governor Sarah Palin to be his running mate. Despite the spin that desperate Republicans immediately parroted, it wasn't a brilliant pick, or a game-changer. It was an amazingly bad choice.

Palin's shortcomings have been documented in an instant feeding frenzy among journalists and bloggers. She is the least known, least experienced VP nominee in modern political history. Those who compare her to George H. W. Bush's choice of Dan Quayle in 1988 forget that Quayle had already been in Congress for 12 years.

By contrast, Palin took office as Governor in December, 2006, less than two years ago. Before that, she served two terms on the city council and then as mayor from 1996-2002 of Wasilla, Alaska, a town with a population under 9,000. That's less than 1/20th the size of the Illinois State Senate district Barack Obama represented for eight years before he was elected to the U.S. Senate.

What a way to undercut McCain's central argument that Obama doesn't have enough experience to serve as president or commander in chief.

Of course, McCain hardly knows her. He first met Palin only in February of this year at a governors' conference, where they spoke for approximately fifteen minutes. The next time he saw her was on Thursday, two days after Hillary Clinton's rousing address to the Democratic Convention. McCain may have been worried about losing diehard Clinton supporters to Hillary's cry of "No way, no how, no McCain!" That morning, he offered her the job.

If he thinks Hillary Democrats will cheer and fall in line behind Sarah Palin, McCain is in for a rude awakening. Palin's gender is the only thing she has in common with Hillary Clinton. She is an extreme right winger who is anti-abortion to the core, doesn't think global warming is man made, and enthusiastically supports oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.

Sarah Palin at her office in Alaska

Billed by McCain as bearing "a message of reform and public integrity," Palin is currently under investigation herself. A few weeks ago, a bipartisan panel of Alaska state legislators appointed an independent investigator to look into charges that Palin abused her office. In mid-July she fired the Alaska public safety commissioner, allegedly after he refused to dismiss her former brother-in-law, a state trooper who divorced Palin's sister three years ago and was locked in a custody dispute over their child.

Announced on his 72nd birthday, this pick follows a string of McCain gaffes, memory lapses, and episodes of forgetfulness on the campaign trail. As reported by Talking Points Memo:

"McCain frequently forgets key elements of policies, gets countries' names wrong, forgets things he's said only hours or days before and is frequently just confused."
It all raises the uncomfortable question of whether McCain might be exhibiting signs of Alzheimer's disease.

I don't take the subject of Alzheimer's lightly. My grandfather died of complications from the disease, and I watched his mind waste away over a period of several painful years. But it's a question that must be asked in view of John McCain's age. If elected, he would be the nation's oldest president in history.

According to the national Alzheimer's Association, the leading voluntary health organization for Alzheimer care, support and research, one of the top ten warning signs of the disease is poor or decreased judgment. The number one warning sign is memory loss.

The last septuagenarian in the White House, Ronald Reagan, exhibited symptoms of forgetfulness and mental degeneration before leaving office, although his Alzheimer's diagnosis was only made public in 1994. Former White House correspondent Lesley Stahl wrote in her book Reporting Live that she and other reporters suspected Reagan was "sinking into senility" as early as 1986, but aides "covered up his condition" and editors chose not to cover it.

History seems to be repeating itself, because the press is not devoting nearly enough attention to McCain's well-documented memory problems.

There are certainly other explanations for why McCain went with Palin. Earlier this summer McCain suggested he might pick a pro-choice running mate, like former Pennsylvania Governor Tom Ridge, and anti-abortion Republicans went ballistic. So he may have caved to the right wing, and delivered up a candidate to their liking.

The National Review gushed over Palin, saying McCain had "wowed the public and enthused the right." Other more clear headed conservatives were a little subdued. Even Republican strategist Ed Rollins, Ronald Reagan's former political director, hedged his bets by calling it a "brilliant, but risky choice" for McCain. Rollins did admit the Republican Party was "in desperate need of young people and women role models."

But this VP pick is the most questionable decision yet from John McCain. He passed over numerous plausible Republican contenders and failed to pick someone remotely qualified for the job.

Going with the white-haired Arizona Senator was once a "safe choice" for voters hesitant to embrace Obama's message of change. Putting Sarah Palin a heartbeat away from the White House has made McCain's candidacy a much bigger risk. It's fair to ask whether John McCain is mentally fit to be president.

(UPDATE 9/1: My Dad, of all people, gave me an interesting scoop about John McCain earlier today that's relevant to this post. Seems he recently met someone who has flown with McCain on multiple occasions. The source says McCain looks much older in person than when made up for TV interviews, it's clear he's "got some serious mileage on him." And although McCain does his best to come across as energetic on the campaign trail, in reality, he can more accurately be described as a "tired old man." These are direct observations from someone who's seen McCain up close and personal more times than most voters ever will, and reinforce concerns about his age. In my Dad's words, this source was "very believable," and that's good enough for me.)

(UPDATE 9/2: Cross-posted to the Huffington Post, this story has drawn a lot of response. It made the top ten list on Digg yesterday, and was Dugg 2,500 times within 24 hours, which tripled its readership on HuffPo to more than 35,000. If you haven't yet watched the video embedded above (a compilation of McCain's memory lapses and confused stumbles on the campaign trail), check it out, and when you’re done, consider forwarding this post to friends.

But I'm hardly the first McCain critic to raise this question. Frank Rich and Josh Marshall have previously written about how the media is ignoring McCain's frequent "senior moments," signs of possible impairment that look awfully familiar to many who have seen a family member or loved one in the early stages of senility. Back in April, MSNBC's Keith Olbermann aired a commentary on "McCain’s Memory" featuring similarly disturbing video. Last Friday, Paul Begala wrote an op-ed for CNN ("Is John McCain Out of His Mind?") that questioned his "shockingly irresponsible" judgment over the Sarah Palin pick.)

Digg It.


keepemhonest said...

I love reading what you write.

Palin has no CREDENTIALS - forget "Experience." The rightwingers are twisting the 'experience' word.

She has no CREDENTIALS in dealing with:

* foreign policy
* national economics
* national border control

John U. said...

My father died of Alzheimer's 'complications' when he was 81.

Dementia onset was diagnosed when he was 70, however. The first sign was his surprise at difficulty finding the right word just as he had formulated a thought and was about to express it. So conversation deteriorated from that point until he was ultimately unable to speak at all except in grunts toward the end. This was a man who did the Sunday NY Times crossword puzzle in 10 minutes flat when he was 60. I watched him do it, and I also saw his deterioration. It was heartbreaking.

My sympathy to you on your loss, and my wholehearted thanks for bringing McCain's mental fitness out into the open.

I am 59, and I am just starting to feel memory-loss symptoms that friends too often attribute to my age. I have found myself equally puzzled at moments in conversation when I had been unable to think of the right word, or a salient name or factoid. I am getting myself tested next week. "...probably just fatigue..." doesn't cut it. My mom has it, too. She's 86.


John U.
New York

Karen K. said...

As a psychiatrist who thinks that Bush's psyche is what has gotten us into so much trouble, who was amazed that everyone didn't see his boasting about his distaste for introspection as a huge red flag, and who became an early Obama supporter after concluding from wide reading that he was that very rare thing, a seriously mentally healthy grown-up, I was pleased to see your piece in the Huffington Post.

Beyond very big questions about his temperament, cognitive style, and possible PTSD, I have become increasingly concerned that McCain is, in fact, showing signs of significant cognitive impairment. I've wondered if he might have early Parkinson's disease with dementia (though his two frozen shoulders do make him look, perhaps misleadingly, stiff.)

It is very distressing that there seems to be so little interest in the media in exploring an issue that is far more relevant to his candidacy than his physical health could be. Journalists seem to be clueless about temperament and cognitive style and their importance in a leader and decision-maker anyway, but to ignore the issue of McCain's possible impairment seems to be a total abdication of their responsibility to the country (if they feel any.)

I'm not clear on how big a soapbox you yourself have, but I encourage you to help keep this issue out there.


Karen K., M.D.


$400 haircuts (3) 1980s (1) 1984 (1) 1988 elections (1) 1989 (1) 1990 elections (2) 1992 elections (1) 1993 (3) 2000 elections (3) 2004 (7) 2004 elections (2) 2008 (32) 2008 congressional races (2) 2012 elections (2) 2014 elections (1) 527 groups (1) 9/11 (4) 9/11 first anniversary (1) Abba Eban (1) abortion (3) action alert (4) activism (1) advertising (2) advocacy (1) affair (4) Affordable Care Act (1) affordable housing fund (1) afghanistan (2) Age of Obama (1) AIDS (1) AIDS victims (2) AIPAC (1) al gore (2) Al Sharpton (1) Alec Guettal (3) alienation (2) alternative energy (10) Alzheimer's (1) amanda marcotte (2) American Left (1) Amnon Rubenstein (1) andrew young (3) Angelo Robinson (1) anti-communism (1) anti-gay bigotry (1) anti-gay violence (1) anti-immigration activists (2) anti-Semitism (1) anti-war (6) appeal to southern voters (1) apprentice (1) Ariel Sharon (1) Ashley Todd (2) assassinations (1) attack ads (3) attack on voter rights (4) Australia (1) average Americans (1) baby boomers (1) baby formula (1) bank of america (1) bankruptcy reform (1) barack obama (24) Barry Commoner (2) BBC (1) Benjamin L. Ginsberg (1) Bensonhurst (1) Beth Ising (2) bi-racial coalition (1) Biden-Palin Debate (1) big money (1) bigotry (7) bill clinton (6) bill donohue (1) Bill Hedrick (1) Billy Bragg (1) Black Cultural Center (1) black voters (6) Blan Holman (1) block the vote (1) bloggergate (1) bloggers (1) blogosphere (1) Bob Dole (1) bob johnson (1) books (2) Borders (2) BP (2) Brad Blog (1) Brad Friedman (1) budget deficit (1) bush (7) Bush Administration (2) bush administration misconduct (2) bush donor (1) bush on steroids (1) bush v. gore (1) California (1) campaign feud (1) campaign finance reform (3) campaign gaffes (2) campaign scandals (4) can edwards win (3) canvassing (1) capitalism (2) Catalyst (5) censorship (5) Cesar Chavez (1) Channel One (1) chapel hill (6) chapel hill town council (3) Charlie Black (1) Chatham County (1) chemical industry (2) children (1) chris hughes (1) Chris Whittle (1) Christine O'Donnell (1) CIA recruiting (1) citizen participation (1) civil disobedience (2) civil rights (7) civilian casualties (2) Civitas Institute (1) class issues (1) Clear Channel (2) Clinton Administration (3) code words (1) Cold War (1) colin powell (1) Colin Small (1) college campuses (2) colonialism (1) columbia (1) community reinvestment (1) community reinvestment act (1) concentration of mass media ownership (3) Concord (1) congress (4) conservation (1) consumer fraud (2) consumers (2) Coors (1) corporate accountability (8) corporate influence (4) corporate media (1) corporate misconduct (7) corporations (8) counter-inaugural (1) CRA (1) cra-nc (2) crony capitalism (1) cultural imperialism (1) Dale McKinley (1) damage control (2) Dana Rohrabacher (1) David Ball (2) David Brower (1) David Horowitz (1) Debbie Cook (1) demagogues (3) democracy (6) Democratic Convention (1) democratic nomination (15) democratic party (2) Democrats (2) Denis Hayes (1) deregulation (1) Dick Cheney (1) dictatorships (1) dirty tricks (4) discrimination (1) disparate treatment (1) diversity (1) divisive politics (3) Dominican Republic (1) Donald Rumsfeld (1) donald trump (1) dumpstering (2) durham (2) e-mail (2) early voting (1) economic inequality (2) economy (3) ed meese (1) Ed Rollins (1) Edison Project (1) edith childs (1) education (1) edwards affair (4) election day 2008 (1) Eliot Spitzer (1) Elizabeth Dole (1) elizabeth edwards (2) Emily Lawson (1) energy independence (9) entertaining ourselves to death (3) environment (15) environmental pollution (5) environmental racism (2) Eric Odell (2) Ericka Kurz (21) evan bayh (1) expenditures (1) exploitation of 9/11 (2) Exxon Valdez (1) factory farming (1) fec (1) feminism (1) Fidel Castro (1) field plan (1) financial house of cards (1) fire (1) Fire From The Mountain (1) firebombing (2) fired up (1) first openly gay elected official in south (1) florida recount (1) foreign policy (1) Fox News (1) fraudulent inauguration (2) Frederick Douglass (1) freedom songs (1) friend (1) fuel efficiency (1) fundraising (2) gary hart (1) gay (6) gay history (2) gay marriage (1) gay-baiting (4) Gaza (2) gen. david petraeus (1) general election (23) Generation X (1) George H.W. Bush (6) George Norris (1) george w. bush (10) Geraldine Ferraro (1) Germany (2) gerrymandering (1) get-out-the-vote (2) global warming (1) GOP (14) GOP Slime Machine (7) GOTV (2) great recession (1) greed (1) grocery store (1) ground game (1) ground zero (1) GSE's (1) guerrillas (1) guest workers (1) Gulf War (5) h+r block (1) hackers (2) Hamas (2) Harriet Ann Jacobs (2) Harris Wofford (1) Harry Blackmun (1) Harry Truman (1) Harvey Gantt (2) hate-mongering (3) hatred (3) health care reform (3) hedge funds (1) Helen Caldicott (2) Henry Hyde (1) Henry Louis Gates Jr. (1) hero (1) Hezbollah (1) hillary clinton (9) history (1) hit the road jack (1) HMO's (1) Ho Chi Minh (1) hoaxes (1) Holocaust (1) home foreclosures (1) homophobia (1) housing (1) HR 1461 (1) Huks (1) hurting communities (1) i feel pretty (1) iit’s a wonderful life (1) immigration (2) immigration reform (2) Inauguration Day 2009 (1) Incidents In The Life of a Slave Girl (2) income inequality (1) Indigo Girls (1) industrial agriculture (1) industrial revolution (1) integration (1) international relations (1) Invasion of Panama (1) iowa caucuses (1) Ira Magaziner (1) iraq (2) iraq war (4) iraq war costs (2) Irgun (1) Israel (5) Israeli Labor Party (1) Israeli-Palestinian conflict (6) James Bay II (1) James Carville (1) james watt (1) January 20 2001 (2) January 20 2009 (1) jeb bush (1) Jenn Karson (1) Jeremiah Wright (1) Jesse Helms (8) jesse jackson (3) Jessecrats (1) Jesus de Galindez (1) JFK Assassination (1) Jill Biden (1) Jim DeMint (1) Jim Hunt (3) Jimmy Langman (3) job losses (3) joe biden (3) joe herzenberg (3) Joe Sestak (1) joe trippi (1) john edwards (12) john kerry (4) John Locke (1) John McCain (15) John Moody (1) john poindexter (1) John Raese (1) John Reich (1) June 24 1973 (1) justice (1) Kansas (1) Karl Marx (1) Karl Rove (3) Ken Calvert (1) Kirti Shastri (1) Korean War (1) Ku Klux Klan (2) labor unions (1) Lakota Woman (1) Lamar Alexander (1) Larry Kissell (1) Latin America (2) Latinos (2) lazy journalism (1) Lebanon (1) lee c. wilson (1) legal system (1) lesbian (1) liberation theology (1) Likud (3) Linda Brent (2) Lisa Abbott (3) lobbying (1) Louisiana (1) love child scandal (2) macaca moment (1) Mark Chilton (2) Mark Kleinschmidt (1) Mark Penn (1) marketing (2) Martin Frost (1) Martin Luther King Jr. (1) Mary Brave Bird (1) Mary Crow Dog (1) Matt Czajkowski (1) max cleland (1) mayor of franklin street (1) mbna (1) McCain missteps (2) McCain VP (7) McCarthyism (1) McDesperate (4) media (2) media bias (2) media hysteria (1) media monopolies (3) medical insurance industry (3) melissa mcewan (1) memorial (1) Menachem Begin (2) mentor (1) merger (1) Michael Stipe (1) Michelle Bachmann (1) michelle malkin (1) middle east (1) Mike Castle (1) Mike Easley (2) military-industrial complex (3) Millennials (1) Milton Wolf (1) mission not accomplished (1) Mitt Romney (3) Mobil (2) molly ivins (1) Moral Majority (2) MOVE (1) multiculturalism (1) multinational corporations (2) mybo (1) NAACP (1) Nat Turner (1) Nathan Sproul (1) Native Americans (2) nc (4) neo-nazis (1) Nestle (1) netroots (3) New Orleans (1) New World Order (1) New York City (1) Nicaragua (2) nobama democrats (1) non-profits (2) North Carolina (14) North Korea (1) nuclear industry (3) Obama Inauguration (1) Obamacare (1) Obsession DVD (1) OCAW (1) occupied territories (2) October 28 2007 (1) offshore drilling (1) oil (10) oil industry (6) oliver north (1) Omar Cabezas (1) online organizing (1) oppression (2) oprah (1) organizing (11) ots (2) outrage (1) overconsumption (1) Palestine (1) pandagon (1) pat buchanan (1) Pat Roberts (1) Pat Toomey (1) patriarchy (2) Paul Wellstone (1) payday lending (1) peace (3) peace is patriotic (1) Pennsylvania (1) Penny Rich (1) petition (2) pharmaceutical industry (1) Phillipines (1) phony billionaire (1) PIRGs (1) PLO (2) police brutality (1) political committees (1) political consultants (1) political heroes (1) pottersville (1) President Obama (1) presidential campaign (29) privatization of education (1) pro-war propaganda (1) profits (1) progressive Democrats (1) property (1) protest (2) protests (5) public opinion (1) publishing industry (2) pulp (1) pulping (2) PUMA (1) race card (1) race relations (5) race riots (2) racism (16) racist terrorism (1) Rafael Trujillo (1) rally (1) ralph nader (3) RALs (1) ray charles (1) reading list (2) reagan's racism (1) recall elections (1) recession of 1991-92 (2) recession of 2008 (1) redbaiting (1) redistricting (1) refugee camps (1) refund anticipation loans (1) Republican National Convention (2) republican party (1) Republican Study Committee (1) returns (2) revolution (1) rielle hunter (2) Right Wing (7) right wing Republicans (4) RIP (2) rip-off (1) Robert Redford (2) Robin Hayes (1) ronald reagan (2) Ruby Sinreich (1) rudy giuliani (1) ruling class (1) rush limbaugh (2) Sabra and Shatilla Massacres (1) Sam Brownback (1) same-sex marriage (1) Sandinistas (1) Sarah Palin (13) savings and loans (1) schools (1) Scientology (1) SDS (1) SEAC (19) selected not elected (1) Senate races (1) sept. 11 (3) sept. 11 2002 (2) sexism (2) Sharron Angle (1) Sheldon Adelson (1) Shimon Peres (1) single payer health system (2) Six-Day War (1) slaveholders (1) slavery (2) Smithfield Foods (1) social movements (1) social networking (1) solar panels (1) soul music (1) south carolina primary (4) spat (1) state governments (1) Steve Schmidt (3) stolen election (4) stop bush (1) strange incidents (2) student activism (17) students (11) subprime lending (1) super PACs (1) superdelegate petition (2) superdelegates (2) supreme court (2) susan baylies (1) swine flu panic (1) Syria (1) take action (13) tax code fairness (1) Tea Party (2) terrorism (1) Terry Sanford (1) The Revolt (1) The Zionist Dream Revisited (1) these guys (1) third world (3) Thomas Frank (1) Threshold (8) tim kaine (1) Time Warner (1) tobacco industry (1) Tom DeLay (1) Tongass National Forest (1) Tony Coelho (1) Tony Mazzocchi (1) Troopergate (1) trump was born wealthy (1) U.S. power structure (2) UNC-Chapel Hill (4) undocumented immigrants (1) unemployment (1) United Kingdom (2) universal healthcare coverage (5) unprovoked war (1) UpStairs Lounge (1) uranium mining (1) US foreign policy (2) US support for Israel (2) Vandana Ramaswamy (1) veepstakes (4) vice president (6) Vietnam War (6) VOE (1) volunteers (5) vote packing (1) voter education (1) voter ID (1) voter mobilization (1) voter registration (9) voter suppression (7) voter turnout (6) voter-owned elections (1) voters (7) voters for obama (2) voting (1) voting problems (1) voting rights (1) vp (1) Waldenbooks (2) walter mondale (1) war (6) war in iraq (5) war on terror (1) war profits (1) War Resisters League (1) war toys (1) war weary (1) waste (2) wealth (1) white supremacy (1) Whittle Communications (1) Winona LaDuke (3) Woodrow Wilson (1) workers (1) World War One (1) xenophobia (1) Yitzhak Rabin (1) you're fired (1) youth (1) youtube (1) Yusef Hawkins (1) Zionism (2)

Rogues Gallery